Thumbs up for "Country Boys"
I'll confess: I didn't think I'd like it. My first impulse is to be suspicious of films about "those poor folks in the hills," which often seem incapable of portraying such people as anything other than stupid hillbillies or pious sufferers.
Thankfully, the two teens whose lives are followed in "Country Boys," Cody and Chris, are made out to be neither. Despite a pretentious-sounding trailer and write-ups that attempt to cast the film as a defining statement about Appalachian poverty, the film itself does a remarkable job of telling these kids' stories on their own terms.
Sutherland pulls off a great balancing act: on one hand, he shows in rich detail the daily issues that folks living in poverty face. We see Chris, for example, missing key school days at the end of the semester -- and thereby sabotaging chances for a timely graduation -- to help his family move their trailer.
These are the daily battles and trade-offs faced by millions of people, which -- added up over time -- go a long way towards defining chances for success or failure. They're also realities that the media and politicians ignore, which is what makes "Country Boys" or Barbara Ehrenriech's Nickel and Dimed necessary, to get America back in touch with its own people.
But at the same time, Sutherland steers clear of making Chris and Cody out to be a strange "other" -- exotic victims that we can feel sorry for but never relate to. Sure, they've had tough lives, don't have much money, and speak with a mountain cadence. But even if those traits don't describe you, Sutherland goes deep enough to reveal that their for struggles for love, security and pride are the same as yours. So watching Chris and Cody go through their lives, making good decisions and bad, you don't just learn about them -- you also learn about yourself.
As a Knight-Ridder reviewer puts it, Sutherland's strength is that he is both honest about poverty, but also helps you understand that "we're all 'Country Boys'":
Alcohol, drugs, teenage pregnancy, emotionally needy parents, the loss of a job. Any one of these things can make the difference between happiness and misery no matter who you are.
At the same time, Sutherland provides constant visual reminders of the pervasive poverty that grips that region. In such conditions, there is almost no margin for error. Either boy's dreams could be disrupted at any moment.


3 Comments:
I, too, was dreading the inevitable "those backwoods folks," but I've really been enjoying it. I can't wait to tonight's!
I'm also impressed with it so far (just watched the first part this evening), but as a teacher in an urban community college, I'm horrified by the teachers in the school. On the one hand, it's obvious that they care and that they're pulling for the kids, but the actual classes shown in the film seemed just terrible. Did the school bother anyone else?
Yeah, a lot of papers have questioned what kind of teacher disputes evolution in the midst of class, but for the most part, I don't question their intentions. I thought the history of the school though was interesting. A teacher from NYC comes down to Appalachia 30 years ago and founded a school which provides a supportive environment for kids at risk. I just wanted to sign them all up for a decent Independent Living Program.
Post a Comment
Return to Facing South's main page